Select your country to learn about local service, view local news and customer and receive support, all in your preferred language.

Inside vs. Outside IR35: Meaning, Calculator & Updates

Last Updated
24th April 2024
Freelancer working online in office
Go Back Blog > Freelancers

As we go through the ever-evolving scenario for freelancers, consultants, and contractors in the UK continues to evolve, especially with changes to the IR35 tax legislation. IR35 is an essential component of the UK tax system that aims to distinguish between genuine self-employment and ‘disguised employment’ where individuals work in similar conditions to employees but are taxed more leniently as contractors. This article aims to clarify the differences between being inside or outside IR35, introduce the utility of IR35 calculators, and highlight the latest legislative changes as of 2024 that impact this regulation.


What Does IR35 Mean?


IR35, also known as the Intermediaries Legislation, was initially introduced in 2000 by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC). It targets tax avoidance by professionals who might otherwise be deemed employees but are working through an intermediary, such as a personal service company. The primary aim is to ensure that workers, who would have been considered employees if they were providing their services directly to a client, pay broadly the same Income Tax and National Insurance contributions as employees.

Under this legislation, understanding whether you are inside or outside IR35 is crucial for determining your tax status. Being inside IR35 means HMRC views you as an employee for tax purposes even if you consider yourself a self-employed contractor. Consequently, you are required to pay tax similarly to an employee, which can significantly affect your net income. On the other hand, if you are outside IR35, you are recognised as genuinely self-employed and can structure your payments for tax efficiency, which typically results in a lower tax burden.

For a detailed breakdown of IR35 and its implications for contractors in the UK, refer to the comprehensive guide. This resource provides an in-depth look at how IR35 might affect your contracting career and outlines strategies to ensure compliance while maximising your take-home pay.


What changed with the IR35 rule in 2024?


The IR35 legislation has undergone significant revisions in 2024, marking a major shift in the way both contractors and the organisations that hire them manage tax compliance. One of the essential changes introduced this year involves the clarification and reinforcement of existing rules, making it more straightforward for all parties to determine the correct employment status of a contractor.

A crucial modification in 2024 is the enhanced responsibility placed on the end-clients in the private sector to determine the IR35 status of their contractors. Previously, the burden of this decision often fell on the contractors themselves, leading to uncertainties and frequent misclassifications. Now, it is imperative for companies utilising contract staff to conduct thorough assessments using detailed criteria provided by HMRC, ensuring that their determinations are accurate and compliant with the law.

Additionally, the 2024 update has introduced measures to mitigate the ‘double taxation’ issue, where both contractors and fee-payers could end up being taxed excessively in scenarios where HMRC reevaluates the employment status of a contractor retrospectively. New regulations allow for more equitable tax calculations by permitting adjustments based on taxes already paid, reducing the financial impact on both parties involved.


Understanding the difference between Inside IR35 and Outside IR35


The distinction between being inside IR35 and outside IR35 is fundamental to how contractors manage their businesses and their overall tax strategy. Understanding this difference is essential for compliance and financial planning.

Inside IR35

If a contract is deemed to be inside IR35, it means that for tax purposes, the contractor is considered an employee of the client company. Therefore, income from that contract is subject to payroll taxes, namely PAYE (Pay As You Earn) and National Insurance contributions, just as it would be for an ordinary employee. This classification generally leads to a higher tax liability compared to being outside IR35. Contractors inside IR35 lose some of the tax advantages typically available to self-employed individuals, such as being able to claim broader expenses.

Outside IR35

A contract that falls outside IR35 allows the contractor to be recognised as an independent business entity. This status affords more flexibility in how income is drawn from the company, typically through a combination of salary and dividends, which can be tax-efficient. Being outside IR35 also enables contractors to retain control over their working arrangements and business decisions, reflecting true business ownership rather than employee status.

The correct classification hinges on several factors determined by HMRC criteria, including the level of supervision, direction, and control over how the work is completed; whether the contractor has the right to send a substitute in their place; and the nature of the contractual terms themselves. Misclassification can lead to significant tax and penalty liabilities, making it crucial for both contractors and the companies they work with to carefully assess each contract.


The Inside IR35 calculator


For contractors concerned about their employment status under IR35, various tools are available to assist in determining whether a particular contract might fall inside IR35. An Inside IR35 Calculator is an essential tool that can help estimate the financial impact of being classified inside IR35. This calculator takes into account your income, the nature of your engagements, and other key factors to simulate the tax liabilities and net income under the IR35 rules. To accurately plan your contracts and understand potential deductions, it’s advisable to use these simulations regularly.

For a practical demonstration of how changes to your contract conditions might affect your IR35 status, you can request a simulation here. This tool provides a detailed analysis, helping you navigate the complexities of IR35 compliance.

Additionally, if you’re looking for an immediate estimation, consider using online calculators from trusted sources like the HMRC’s own tools or other financial websites that specialise in contractor tax scenarios. It’s important to choose a calculator that is updated regularly to reflect the latest tax rules and legislation changes.


Calculating Your Status with an Outside IR35 Calculator


Understanding the complexities of IR35 status can be challenging, but an Outside IR35 Calculator provides a vital resource for contractors who manage their own businesses. This tool helps you understand and organise your working arrangements to ensure they are compliant with HMRC’s criteria for operating outside of IR35, thus retaining the tax efficiencies of being recognised as a genuine independent contractor.

By inputting details about your working practices, contract terms, and engagement specifics, the calculator assesses your likelihood of being outside IR35. The results can guide you in making informed decisions about contract negotiations and how you structure your work engagements to maintain compliance with IR35 rules.

For contractors looking to optimise their tax position and safeguard against potential misclassification, these calculators serve as an invaluable first step in evaluating the nature of contractual work. Remember, while these tools provide a preliminary assessment, they should be complemented with professional advice from tax experts or legal consultants specialising in contractor law to ensure full IR35 compliance. Feel free to use our IR35 simulation calculator tool and speak to one of our experts to make sure you are in compliance with IR35.


How Hightekers helps freelancers to overcome any issue with IR35


Hightekers helps freelancers comprehend the complexities of IR35 legislation through a unique model. By offering freelancers permanent contracts, Hightekers positions itself not just as a support system but as an employer, thereby simplifying the IR35 compliance process. This arrangement allows freelancers to focus on their projects without the usual concerns associated with IR35 status evaluations and tax complexities. Through this proactive approach, Hightekers ensures that freelancers can confidently manage their engagements, optimising their tax positions while remaining compliant with IR35 rules.

Expert Guidance on IR35 Compliance

Partnering with Hightekers provides more than just expert advice; it ensures comprehensive support for IR35 compliance. Hightekers’ specialists, deeply knowledgeable about the latest IR35 legislation, offer personalised consultations not just as advisors but as part of the employer team. This unique structure allows freelancers to have their contracts and working arrangements regularly assessed, ensuring they align with IR35 requirements. 

Proactive Contract Reviews

Hightekers overcomes  the concerns surrounding IR35 by employing freelancers directly. This approach ensures that freelancers are no longer just independent contractors but are part of an organisational structure that inherently complies with IR35. Through Hightekers’ employment model, the typical complexities and risks of contract evaluations for IR35 are managed by the company, allowing freelancers to focus fully on their professional assignments without the worry of IR35 classification. These reviews look at factors such as control, substitution, and mutuality of obligation, which are crucial in determining IR35 status. With Hightekers’ support, freelancers can negotiate contracts that not only protect them from IR35 but also align with their professional goals and requirements.

Administrative Support and Simplified Tax Handling

For freelancers juggling multiple clients and projects, managing administrative tasks and tax obligations can be overwhelming. Hightekers simplify these processes by handling administrative duties and providing guidance on tax-efficient practices.

By offering a centralised platform for managing invoices, payments, and tax submissions, Hightekers ensures that freelancers maintain proper records and comply with HMRC requirements. This structured approach is vital in demonstrating the independence necessary to remain outside IR35.

By integrating these services, Hightekers not only helps contractors understand the complexities of IR35 but also enhances their overall business operations, making it easier to thrive in a competitive and regulated environment.

Share this story

Get in touch to know more

    By submitting your personal information to this website, you consent to such information being treated in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.